Monotonic reduction in viscoelasticity / β-sheet signal
Same review
ALK-tagged RADA16 (+3 hydrophobic residues)
Rapid collapse to spherical aggregates
Same review
>50 aa globular domain
Never tested in published literature
—
Our tail91 construct: 118 aa
UNCHARACTERIZED, ~10× beyond empirical limit
—
Red flags in current h09 Phase 4d/4e model
Model constant
Value
Problem
RADA16_MONOMERS_PER_NM_FIBRIL = 4.35
comment “Zhang MIT”
Value defensible (2% off 4.26). Comment misleading — Zhang 1993 provides no such number. Correct citation: Cormier 2012 (WAXD H-bond spacing) + Paravastu 2014 (bilayer model).
fibril_length_nm = 1000
inline
Defensible as upper-range AFM value; mean ~615 nm (Yokoi 2005). Flag as upper bound.
RADA16_FIBRILS_PER_CROSSSECTION = 5 (avg)
—
Geometrically plausible (10–20 nm bundle / 3 nm tape width = 3–7 fibers/bundle). Not directly stated in any paper.
K_PROTEOLYSIS = 1.4/h (t½ 30 min)
“conservative”
Wrong regime. For assembled gel, in vivo t½ is 7–14 days → k ≈ 0.002–0.004/h. Model is 350–700× faster than reality in the error-safe direction (overestimates clearance). Need to split: k_gel_dissolution (slow, scaffold at delivery site) vs k_free_monomer_proteolysis (fast, for peptide monomers that haven’t assembled).
118 aa tail on RADA16
core design assumption
NOT IN CHARACTERIZED PARAMETER SPACE. Empirical limit for sequence modification preserving assembly is ~12 residues. Our tail is 10× beyond. Rigorous path: 9:1 molar blend (plain RADA16 : RADA16-tail91) where plain scaffold carries assembly and tail91 displays WH2/TMEM145-binder on surface. Documented in literature for similar hybrids (Gelain osteogenic). Must be added to Phase 4e design.
Critical implication
h09 Phase 3b PEPTIDE_TAIL91 cannot be assumed to self-assemble at 100% composition. Every dose calculation in Phase 4e that treats the entire administered peptide as contributing to the functional scaffold is 10× too optimistic if a 9:1 blend is used (only 10% of mass is functional). Alternatively, if pure tail91 is used, assembly likely fails entirely.