What they found
Dominguez’s authoritative review arguing that tandem WH2 domain repeats (Spire, Cobl, VopL/VopF, Sca2) are insufficient to drive efficient actin nucleation on their own — other domains or cooperating proteins are always required. Mechanistic review of WH2 family across all WH2-containing nucleators.
Numbers that matter
WH2 × G-actin Kd (from text):
- “Most WH2 domains bind ATP-actin with low micromolar and, in some cases, nanomolar affinity”
- No specific numbers in text; references primary papers (Chereau 2005, Rebowski 2010, etc.)
- The “nanomolar” cases likely refer to full-context domains (WAVE with Arg-Arg in LKKT, or long WH2 constructs with favorable electrostatics)
WH2 × F-actin side-binding:
- NOT measured in this review; no Kd reported
- Review discusses that tandem WH2 domains can coexist with F-actin contacts during nucleation (i.e., they template filament-like arrangements of monomers) but this is mechanistically distinct from side-binding a preformed filament
Key mechanistic point:
- WH2 binds the barbed-end groove of G-actin (subdomains 1/3 cleft)
- In F-actin, this same surface is involved in longitudinal actin–actin contacts along the long-pitch helix — partially inaccessible for independent high-affinity side-binding
- The remaining accessible surface of F-actin does not constitute a structurally coherent independent WH2 binding site
Significance for h09
This review directly supports the concern flagged in the model: WH2 is canonically a G-actin binding motif; its use as an F-actin cross-linker/bundling agent lacks structural precedent. The review explicitly states WH2 is “necessary but insufficient” for nucleation even in tandem — making it further implausible as a standalone F-actin bundler at μM affinity.
Connections
- STRC H09 WH2 F-actin Bundling Hypothesis — Dominguez is the domain expert; this review is the most comprehensive source on WH2 biophysics
- Hydrogel Phase 4d F-actin Bundling Model — supports flagging WH2_KD_FACTIN_M = 5 μM as speculative/unsupported
- 2026-04-23-chereau-wh2-actin-pnas — same author’s original structural paper